By Alice Hill
RealTechNews
We have been pointing to YouTube videos for some time – the website has Saturday Night Live snippets and all sorts of absurd video that actually makes us laugh and look at moving images (a first for me over other sites anyway). But a site upgrade that slowed the system down coupled with the recent decision to delete questionable material without firm guidelines has made faithful users blow their stacks.
“Yesterday, blogger and longtime YouTuber Miel Vanopstal lost his cool in a post titled “Screw YouTube.” Vanopstal complains that YouTube’s recent upgrades have made the site significantly slower, and that new efforts to enforce copyright and delete otherwise questionable material strike him as arbitrary. He is particularly galled that a single alert notice from a “puritanically minded” fellow user can result in a video being deleted. “I’ve had it with these random rejections,” he writes.
“Vanopstal is hardly alone. A bitter Nathan Weinberg at InsideGoogle says that he was kicked off YouTube two months ago. Weinberg chronicles his dissatisfaction with the free (and reportedly money-losing) service, ultimately deciding that he has only one thing left to do: “Ruin YouTube” by systematically reporting all of the site’s traffic-generating but copyright-violating videos. Microsoft’s Don Dodge, who formerly worked at Napster (Research), adds a been there, done that post to the fray, noting sagely: “User-generated content is very difficult to manage and control.”‘ Source: Business 2.0
We Say: We agree. User managed and driven content is difficult to control. Try TinyPic for a look at another service, and hopefully YouTube will get its technology and policies in order and not blow this one. They had me at You. However, they also had a lot of problems with user-posted illegal material and no real way to make money, so this also could be good-bye. Or good-by.
Before you go…try these:
–First-Ever Case of an Entire Company Being Pirated < --Scary
–RANT: Why Wal-Mart’s Build Your Own PC Plan is Doomed
–Regency TR-1: The World’s First iPod
–Hundreds of FREE Tech Magazines < --Nice!
–Iron Mountain Loses Valuable Back Up Tapes
…..Give me more RealTechNews



It is always ironic that the worst clients anyone can have are those that get something for free.
Get a life, people. YouTube is fun, but if you really think you are entitled to your version of reality with someone trying to generate a profit then do what they did: spend the bucks and shut the hell up.
/rant over
If you don’t like YouTube, don’t use it. Quit whining. If you’re so appalled by their subtle changes they integreated to protect copyrighted material AND themselves from getting lawsuits, host your own videos. Stop complaining about a service that saves you loads of monthly bandwidth charges. K? Thanks, bye.
Good God man, don’t kill the messenger!
I think you are confusing the author of the report (me) with some of the people quoted and what they are doing out of anger. I have said I like YouTube a lot – although I do wonder how it will make money. I also feel with this recent backlash, it needs to get the users happy again if possible and the legal situation sorted out, asnd that is not easy when they are at cross purposes.
How is two upset users a major revolt? The last number I saw, 35 million people a day or something like that were going to YouTube. They sound like power users with lots of videos, but it’s still basically two pissed-off guys. Just shows the power of blogs, I guess.
Good point. Someone shut YouTube down though with all this – the URL is hosed.
That does it. They’re hosed.
Looks like it’s working now.
personally I’d be glad if YouTube went away, and all services like it; flash, google video, et al.. if I watch something online I expect to be able to save it, not just bookmark it.. these retarded read only ‘view on demand’ video services are backwards, pathetic and completely superfluous, just like the people who use them..
Folks, I hate to explain basic economics, but the site is NOT free. Every user pays by looking at ads, and possibly buying things. Just like your TV – have you ever complained about a TV show? I bet you have. We pay for all of these things with our time, our attention, and even our money. That’s how these sites stay in business (when they do). So your rants about “free” show a remarkable lack of understanding. Many things in life are not free, but do not require an immediate payment of money (roads, libraries, web sites…).
Folks, I hate to explain basic economics, but the site is NOT free. Every user pays by looking at ads, and possibly buying things. Just like your TV – have you ever complained about a TV show? I bet you have. We pay for all of these things with our time, our attention, and even our money. That’s how these sites stay in business (when they do). So your rants about “free” show a remarkable lack of understanding. Many things in life are not free, but do not require an immediate payment of money (roads, libraries, web sites…).
YouTube has ads? I never noticed…
Oh… and Richard?
Thanks for explaining basic economics to us (even though you hated to). The site is ‘free’ in the context that is being used here. Meaning, you don’t pay money for the videos you watch.
It must be so much fun to hang out with you…
YouTube Users Revolt
As any company grows, it goes through changes. YouTube which is user-driven is no exception. With their popularity came threats over copyrighted videos and now with a major interface change and fuzzy guidelines, some of YouTube’s users are upset.Fro…
YouTubeRobot.com today announces YouTube Robot 2.0, a tool that enables you to download video from YouTube.com onto your PC, convert it to various formats to watch it when you are on the road on mobile devices like mobile phone, iPod, iPhone, Pocket PC, PSP, or Zune.
YouTube Robot allows you to search for videos using keywords or browse video by category, author, channel, language, tags, etc. When you find something noteworthy, you can preview the video right in YouTube Robot and then download it onto the hard disk drive. The speed, at which you will be downloading, is very high: up to 5 times faster than other software when you download a single file and up to 4 times faster when you download multiple files at a time.
Manual download is not the only option with YouTube Robot. You may as well schedule the download and conversion tasks to be executed automatically, even when you are not around. Downloading is followed by conversion to the format of your choice and uploading videos to a mobile device (if needed). For example, you can plug in iPod, select the video, go to bed, and when you wake up next morning, your iPod will be ready to play new YouTube videos.
Product page: ww w.youtuberobot.com
Direct download link: ww w.youtuberobot.com/download/utuberobot.exe
Company web-site: ww w.youtuberobot.com