Pssst...Subscribe to Our Free Newsletter  
 

THE LATEST NEWS
Monday, February 07, 2005

Orkut Isn't Just Another Pretty Face
Last year, when Google sort of seeped out Orkut, "...an online trusted community Web site designed for friends. The main goal of our service is to make the social life of yourself and your friends more active and stimulating," according to the Web site, which states that the service is "in affiliation with Google," the company probably thought it was doing one of the La-di-dah, let's all be happy, hold hands, and sing Kumbayah things. Well, perhaps it hadn't noticed that the Web tends to make things soil themselves. Rather than eHarmony.com, this week, with nearly 6 million people having passed through the Orkut portal, some now congregate at in communities that advance a hatred for Jews, blacks or gays, including a "Death to the Jews" site and a site called "Death to Blacks." Think of it as the WWW turned KKK.

- By now no one should be surprised that people use the Internet to spread repugnant views about race, religion or sexuality. But what is different about Orkut, online specialists say, is that the hate-filled dialogues are taking place inside a members-only social network site that--at least in theory--strictly forbids this kind of conduct in its user's agreement. For Google, the trouble on Orkut--which is still in beta, or test, form--could easily escalate. A prosecutor in Brazil, where the service is especially popular, has already initiated an investigation into some of the more virulent Orkut sites.
A Google spokeswoman, Eileen Rodriguez, wrote in an e-mail message, "There are instances when orkut.com members misuse the service, but it is a very small number compared to everyone who uses it. There is a certain amount of trust we have to place in our users." Google wouldn't pinpoint the number of people signed up for Orkut, but characterized it as "millions."
Orkut members are required to follow the company's "terms of service and community standards," Rodriguez wrote, which state that "an account cannot upload, transmit or contain material that is hateful or offensive based on race, ethnicity, national origin, religion, gender or sexual orientation."
According to Lee Rainie, director of the Pew Internet and American Life Project. "What we're seeing is the havoc that the Internet wreaked on plenty of business is now playing out in the social world."
   4 comments      Email this Link


Comments on this Item:
 
Sounds like Google is taking the 'no responsibility' route on this one. To claim that it's only a few who are offending is just stupid - it's only been a few in history who have been the truest psychotics pushing hatred and violence.

Can't Google whip up some code that searched for keywords like "kill" or "death to" and "jews" and if they're in x proximity in the same sentence, it's flagged for moderator review and rapid deletion?

Or is someone going to break out the blood stained violin and give us a dirge about free speech rights?



 
So...where does free speech end? Does it only extend to that which is pleasent to hear? Do these people not have the right to believe and say whatever they wish, however repugnant and reprehensible it may be? And do we not have the power to ignore them and their disgusting ideals?

Still, there is another question: does Google have the right to censor speech on its own servers? I think they do. These people will always manage to find a forum, and if it were up to me, it wouldn't be on Orkut. But it's not up to me. It's Google's call to make.



 
Free speech is really a moot point here. They have a TOS that strictly forbids certain topic, so while 99% of what people post is ok and gives the semblance of having full and complete freedom it’s not the case. In fact, since they forbid users to post topics along those lines it almost seems like they should be required to review and possibly delete offending posts. Just my $.02


 
Here we are at the boundary of that region which shouldn't be crossed into here... Still, the number of times politics and computing cross have become an amazement to me.

The First AmendmentCongress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.Note the words, "Congress shall make no law..." That's the Constitutionality of the issue. Anything beyond that is interpretation. As well, the Constitution does not guarantee a person the right to be heard.



Post a Comment

 

 
 

The RealTechNews Official Collection of Interesting Technical Websites
(In Alphabetical Order)

RealTechNews.com -Hooray!

All About Technology
Apolemia
As the Apple Turns
Adam Bosthworth
Channel 9
Cincom Smalltalk Blog
CodeStore
CompHobby.org
CreativeBits
Cult of Mac
Daily Dose of Excel
Dan Bricklin's Log
Dan Gilmore
eHomeUpgrade
Engadget
Enterprise System Spectator
Fozbaca.org
Fullasagoog
Future Now
Gadgeteer
Gadgetopia
Gadgetryblog

Gemal's Psyched Blog
Geomblog
Gizmo
Gizmodo
 

Good Morning Silicon Valley
Google Blog
Google Weblog
Hack a Day
Hack the Planet
Hackdiary
Impact Lab
Internet Alchemy
I4U
IT Facts
Java.blogs
Joel on Software
Jonathan's Blog
Live Digitally
Lynch, Kevin
Matt Heerema
Mavromatic
Mehack
MobileMag
MobileWhack
Mobitopia
MSNsearch's WebLog
Napsterization.org
Onlineblog.com
PatrickWeb
Paul's Time Sink
Picturephoning.com
Player Blog
Ployer Technology News
 
PVRblog
Release 4.0
RFID Privacy
Scripting News
Scriptygoddess
Search Engine Watch
Shiny Shiny
SiliconBeat
Six Apart
Slashdot
SpaceNews
Swaine's World
Tech Digest
Techdirt
Threadwatch.org
Tip of the Day
UberGizmo
Unofficial Google Weblog
Unofficial Yahoo Weblog
Useit.com
Web-Graphics
What Ralph Knows
Wi-Fi Networking News
Wingedpig.com
Wohl, Amy
Wrist Dreams
Yahoo! Search Blog 
 

 

Don't See Your Favorite Tech Site Here? Contact Us to Add it Today!

 

(Please!!)
 
Subscribe with Bloglines

Hey Gang! Please sign our guestbook and say hello to the whole RealTech community: independent tech lovers like you. Take a sec to say hello. -- Sign it!

Please help us stay independent. Donate whatever you can today. (Even $1 will make a HUGE difference.)


 


Email the Editors

RealTechNews.com

Google
Search Our Website:
Web RealTechNews.com


Hosted by: Dreamhost
Underground Networks, Inc. Copyright 2005
All Rights Reserved

Place a Text Ad on RealTechNews

 
 
 
Sign up for PayPal and start accepting credit card payments instantly.